I have already been blowing him off for a while. He doesn't know anything about media nor does he have a drive to scan in so I figured it might be a way to get rid of crap media, and he will buy whatever replacment media I tell him to (cmcmagaf1 for verbatium sound pretty good since verbatium is on sale this week). You guy are right though. Either they won't play and he will give up or he will come to expect it from me which could really turn into a hassle, plus who knows if they are his disks. I supose that you could say that if the disk is in his posession it's his disk, if he gives the disk to someone else (or back to someone else), thats no diffrent than him legally backing it up himself and then giving away the disk and ilegally keeping the backup, so it's on his head. The more I think about it, the more its probably not worth the trouble or my time(I only have about 125 crappy disks that I have had for ever). They are handy for testing and franklly, my 3500 can burn them well enough that they play fine (pi spikes around 80 max) so for non important stuff, I could always use them myself. I think I am just going to blow him off. It could be to much trouble to have to deal with him after the crap media was gone if I did. I supose that I could intentionally make bad burns (neither of my other burners will burn this stuff good) just to screw with him and get him to give up on it. That might be fun.