They’re all equal in their scanning abilities.
With that said, no 2 drives scan exactly alike. But all the drives you listed tend to be somewhat similar in their scanning. There is no “best” from that list, really.
Just decide whether or not you want LightScribe. A1L has LightScribe, A1S doesn’t.
Note the A1x drives are somewhat older, just for the sake of knowing. That shouldn’t have much of an impact. Quality of the drives are pretty much equal.