PX-W2410A and op flashpoint SD2 ? 1:1 not working

I have a PX-W2410A and win xp and also a SD-M1612 TOSHIBAdvd … I have op flashpoint a sd2 game… I want to make a 1:1 backup i have clonecd 3… latest and i can make a image as i have read at slow speed with just the fast eror skip set to 5 and no repair… my working backup will work in the dvd toshiba and a plextor 8x4x10 ide but it will not work from my plextor ? can anyone help me…? i have tryed loads of settings aslo i have got the 1.2 firmware ?