I updated the firmware on the driver and changed the discs to be written in DVD-Rom mode, nothing really helped.
I returned the unopened packages of discs. I went through 9 discs total trying different things in an attempt to get them to work, thankfully they were cheap. After this experience I think that I will stay with burning single layer DVD-Rs. They seem to be much more compatible than DL and the quality doesn't appear to be any different than the originals after compressing. Well thanks for the help everyone!