Peer-2-Peer (P2P) file-swapping services

vbimport

#1

Hello!
If peer-2-peer (P2P) file-swapping services like Kazaa, Morpheus, Grokster, etc., are illegal, then why don’t those sites get shut down by the authorities like Napster did?


#2

God question, i wana know 2.


#3

Believe me, the authorities want to, but there is a legal issue involved here…territory issue as well…
Napster became too big and too well known, so it was ‘attacked’ first. Torrent may be next, but that has a whole different structure of distribution, which makes it far more difficult to sue it…but that is a whole lot of legal mumbo jumbo…


#4

sigh

Bit Torrent itself isn’t illegal. It’s just a medium by which people share files. If the files they share aren’t theirs to legally share, then the act of sharing them is illegal… not the medium by which they do the sharing.

Follow?

Napster was shut down because they actually kept files on their servers. That got them in HUGE trouble.

Other companies like Grokster have gotten in trouble because their servers actively enable people to find those files. It “encourages illegal activity”.

Bit Torrent… the trackers could get shut down if they move illegal activity, but how can you “shut down” a program that people run that has no servers? You can’t.