New slim drive for my laptop, 3 choices

I’m looking to ditch my clunky USB enclosure and get an internal DVD/RW drive

I’ve got 3 choices for my Compaq laptop

Philips SPD8005BM/17

Lite-On SSW-8015S

Sony/NEC Optiarc AD-5540A

Anyone have any experience with the above drives or brands? I’m actually looking for the best at audio cd extraction.

Only brand on that list I’ve used is Lite-On, I have a LTR-2412 24x CD/RW and it was goodfor it’s time.