It may help to change the extraction method from a Secure Mode to a Synchronized Mode (I think the Fast Mode is the only one available).
Look at the disc in a good light. You will notice a slightly less reflective ring around the outermost edge of the data tracks. This is a fake TOC designed to confuse your drive and PC. With a black permanent marker, draw over that ring. If the disc is full of phony data tracks after the audio tracks, you don't even have to be particularly careful when blacking out the fake TOC.
After you do this, EAC may recognize the disc, but have trouble reading it, depending on what drive you use. It may help to extract only one track at a time.
More advanced versions of this protection interweave the data tracks and the fake TOC, making it a pain to get around.