Why limit your options to IDE only?...particularly when you just purchased an excellent SATA ODD.
JMO, but there's no contest here.
Take xtacydima's advice and pop a SATA controller card into a free PCI slot.
I installed a Rosewill RC-212 VIA PCI SATA 1.5G / IDE ATA 133 Controller Card about 18 months ago and it's been great. Got it for $19.99 back then.