I think it COULD work if we asked people/members to ONLY post THEIR EXPERIENCE with THEIR CD/DVD player/writer , and if they had TROUBLE how they resolved it ( themself or with help from the manufacture or from members of a forum like cdfreaks.com )
They could also comment that they NEVER HAD any problems with their CD/DVD player/writer since purchase
take a look at www.dslreports.com and you'll see ALL DSL providers gets negative comments, but that doesnt stop some member from choosing that company, it just make us investigate more about that company. Opinions are used for references and not necessarily for final decision on purchase.
thanks for all replies.