> No, I was attempting to run the copy on the same drive I created the disc with.
Yes, but was the game installed from that drive?
> What is a "sheep" drive, I dont know what that means?
It is a categorisation of how accurately the drive does efm encoding of regular bit patterns (in English, how accurately it writes the weak sector patterns that form the most important part of safedisc 2/3/4 copy protection.
> Just as an FYI, I didn't use SD 2/3, I just used SD as the datatype.
Since your writer is a 1 sheep model, you'll need to use sd 2/3 not sd as the datatype to have a realistic chance of success. Try again with sd 2/3 datatype settings and use a cdrw in the first instance.