Most Blu-ray players support other formats these days. Which is why there are not many good Blu-ray conversion/authoring programs available. The ones that are available, from various companies like DVDFab, Aiseesoft, or Leawo often cut corners in order to enable best possible speed, and the quality [B]always[/B] suffers as a result.
VSO, the makers of ConvertXtoDVD, have one you can try called VSO Video Converter: http://www.vso-software.fr/products/video-converter/vso-video-converter.php I have not tried this one myself.
I don’t use an all in one solution personally, but can make a Blu-ray that is fully compliant to specifications of that format using free tools as long as I don’t want a menu. But the tools I use for that are not one-click simple. If you are interested, they are MeGUI to make a fully compliant raw .h264 video stream and AC3 audio stream, and Easy BD Lite to author to Blu-ray format.