CMCMAGAE1 scan BETTER than MXLR03?

wow, I just got done backing up a game with dvdDecrypter… so I did a Pif scan on it, it didnt turn out so good…so being curious, I burned another copy to a memorex DVD-R (CMCMAGAE1)… heres the results…
BTW does anyone think the Philips 1.8 FW will fare better?

that MXLRG03 scan doesnt look bad, but that CMC Mag scan is impressive for CMC Mag. CMC MAG does have its good batches, but in general, its not very good.