Glad you have come out of the closet to join us. I don't have this title to try, but if the original plays OK on the same drive you are using to read it into DVDFab, then Fab is failing to read the IFO file correctly(or to follow its instructions). This may be due to a mulltitude of causes including copy protection, read errors etc. Have you tried using the Customize/No Menus mode? Use your hard drive as a target while testing to avoid enlarging your coaster collection. If you have ignore read errors selected in Common Settings-->Read, try the other option ("Ask...").