5116 picture looks like a VHS VCR

my 5005 broke so I bought a new 5116 from Costco. The picture coming out of 5116 looks like a VHS VCR. Not even close to what I had from 5005. I tried both component and progressive video outputs the results is pretty much the same. I though I had a bad unit so I exchanged one and it looked pretty much the same. Help!!

Return it and look for a Panasonic DMR ES15