external vs internal dvd burner?

Hello guest,: To benefit from all extra features you need to log in or sign up.

BenQ / Philips Writer Discuss, external vs internal dvd burner? at CD and DVD Writers forum; Hello, I have an internal Philips 8701 dvd burner, which is working perfectly. I have been using it a long time, and know that eventually it is going to die. I would like to get a back-up burner before that happens, however, I have not been able to locate a

Posted: 15-03-2007

dustman (CD Freaks Junior Member): Posts: 63

Hello,

I have an internal Philips 8701 dvd burner, which is working perfectly. I have been using it a long time, and know that eventually it is going to die. I would like to get a back-up burner before that happens, however, I have not been able to locate a new or used 8701 anywhere, and assume new would be less risky in any case.

I was thinking that an external burner (usb connection) would be a lot more convenient to use with different computers, but don't know if there are any drawbacks with the external versions as vs internal.

I was able to pick up a used Iomega Super DVD burner, in like new condition, with disks, box, cords and all. It plays perfectly but I have never been able to get a good burn from it. One error message after another, lots of coasters, even though I am using the same program and Verbatim disks, set to the same (low) recording speed.

So, internal vs external? Pros? Cons? 8701's anywhere you know of? (I heard it was the same as a BenQ 1620. Any truth to that?)

Any help would be greatly appreciated,

Thanks,

Dusty

Quote and reply

Today (MyCE Staff): Posts: 15,596

Posted: 15-03-2007

pinto2 (DVD Freak): Posts: 7,545

Dell branded Philips 8701 is a rebadged BenQ DW1640.

Your drive is probably out of warranty so please check this thread how to crossflash 8701 to DW1640.
But if your drive works perfectly don't mess with it, you'll only gain scaning (and QSuite's QScan) capability.

All pros goes for drive mounted internal if you don't need to transport burner between compus far away from each other.
You can run external BenQ (or Sony DRU-810UL) firmware on internal drive, althogh I wouldn't recommend it because the updates for external 1640 version (EW164B) are long due.

Quote and reply

Posted: 16-03-2007

McstylisT (MyCE Member): Posts: 235

Quote:

Originally Posted by pinto2

Dell branded Philips 8701 is a rebadged BenQ DW1640.

Your drive is probably out of warranty so please check this thread how to crossflash 8701 to DW1640.
But if your drive works perfectly don't mess with it, you'll only gain scaning (and QSuite's QScan) capability.

All pros goes for drive mounted internal if you don't need to transport burner between compus far away from each other.
You can run external BenQ (or Sony DRU-810UL) firmware on internal drive, althogh I wouldn't recommend it because the updates for external 1640 version (EW164B) are long due.

Very true Pinto2, and a bit of a downside. But the EW164B firmware is still able to produce some exceptional burns for me. I have a OEM 1640 and use the 164B firmware as i think its faster and is better alround. Produces lower PIF and PIE on burns too.

The EW164B firmware get my vote

From a 164B firmware user.

__________________
McT
McstylisT-Forums • Index page

Quote and reply

Posted: 16-03-2007

pinto2 (DVD Freak): Posts: 7,545

Quote:

Originally Posted by McstylisT

...The EW164B firmware get my vote

From a 164B firmware user.

Yes, BenQ EW164B firmware might be old but still very media compatible.

For average Joe not interested in scanning (btw, not needed at all when you go with quality media), I still recommend Sony DRU-810UL/T firmwares. Their latest is just a few months old.

Quote and reply

Posted: 16-03-2007

dustman (CD Freaks Junior Member): Posts: 63

Hello, Pinto 2,

Thanks for the response! You have given me food for thought. I will go with the internal vs external burner.

Thanks,

Dustman

Quote and reply

Listen up, we've got more. Product information on 107,830 products. Our experts have written 523 articles. We've gathered 16,131 news items for you to always keep updated.