Question: need a drive for quality scanning

Hello guest,
default
To benefit from all extra features you need to log in or sign up.
CD and DVD Writers Discuss, need a drive for quality scanning at Computer Hardware forum; i would like to know what is the best dvd drive(s) currently available on newegg for quality scanning, excluding plextors, i read that the benq 1620 and 1640 are the best but these are expensive and rare in the US, thanks

Old Posted: 01-12-2008
default_avatar
wontellyou (BugMeNot loser account)
Posts: 22
  • Find More Posts by wontellyou
i would like to know what is the best dvd drive(s) currently available on newegg for quality scanning, excluding plextors,

i read that the benq 1620 and 1640 are the best but these are expensive and rare in the US,

thanks
default_avatar
Today (MyCE Staff)
Posts: 15,596
Old Posted: 01-12-2008
vroom's Avatar
vroom (Moderator)
Posts: 3,963
  • Find More Posts by vroom
liteon is the choice if you cant get a true benq or plextor.
__________________
You put me down, For the very last time,
I hit the floor, But I got up on the count of nine,
Goodbye, don't cry, When I'm gone.
Old Posted: 01-12-2008
DrageMester's Avatar
DrageMester (Retired Moderator)
Posts: 17,070
  • Find More Posts by DrageMester
Depends on whether you need quality scanning for DVDs, CDs or both.
No currently produced drive is best for both types of scanning.
__________________
Do not meddle in the affairs of dragons, for you are crunchy and taste good with ketchup.
Old Posted: 01-12-2008
vroom's Avatar
vroom (Moderator)
Posts: 3,963
  • Find More Posts by vroom
Yes I forgot that part Drage, liteon drives are ok for dvd's and Optiarc drives for cd's.
__________________
You put me down, For the very last time,
I hit the floor, But I got up on the count of nine,
Goodbye, don't cry, When I'm gone.
Old Posted: 01-12-2008
BurningFish's Avatar
BurningFish (CD Freaks Senior Member)
Posts: 369
  • Find More Posts by BurningFish
Optiarc drives can scan CD but the results differ a lot compared with BenQ and Plextor, which produce nearly equal results. So for me no actual drive is realy capable for reliable CD scanning. For DVD LiteOn is clear the best choice.
Old Posted: 01-12-2008
default_avatar
wontellyou (BugMeNot loser account)
Posts: 22
  • Find More Posts by wontellyou
thank you for the responses,

i'm mostly interested in scanning dual layer dvds,

can you suggest which models specifically?
Old Posted: 01-12-2008
vroom's Avatar
vroom (Moderator)
Posts: 3,963
  • Find More Posts by vroom
All liteon can scan dual layer discs, but not all liteon drives can do jitter on the second layer.
The DH20A3P can do jitter on the second layer, also i think that the new 122/222/322/422 can do jitter on the second layer (not 100% sure).
__________________
You put me down, For the very last time,
I hit the floor, But I got up on the count of nine,
Goodbye, don't cry, When I'm gone.
Old Posted: 01-12-2008
BurningFish's Avatar
BurningFish (CD Freaks Senior Member)
Posts: 369
  • Find More Posts by BurningFish
Quote:
Originally Posted by wontellyou View Post

i'm mostly interested in scanning dual layer dvds,

can you suggest which models specifically?
As vroom said LiteOn is ok for that also has sometimes problems with second layer, when jitter test is enabled. Other actual drives even doesn't be able to scan jitter at all so it is no disadvantage for me. If you want jittertest also with DL you can look after an old BenQ 1640, 1655. They do jittertest on DL burns without any problem and are perfect CD scanners also, which the LiteOns are not.
There's more to MyCE.com

Listen up, we've got more. Product information on 107,830 products. Our experts have written 523 articles. We've gathered 16,131 news items for you to always keep updated.

Active Commenters

Posting Rules

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
All times are GMT +2. The time now is 10:28.
Top